August 13, 2024

Five Recruiting Practices You Should Ditch in 2024

Is your hiring process stuck in the past? It’s time to rethink your recruitment strategies to attract top talent and stay competitive. Here are five outdated practices we’re leaving behind in 2024, and what you could do instead to improve your hiring outcomes.
9 min read
Profile photo of Deniz Erduran
Deniz Erduran
Account Executive
Blog post Hero Image

As the job market evolves, so do the needs and expectations of candidates. It’s time to rethink your approach to attract the best candidates and meet your hiring goals. Keep reading to find out how you can leave these common practices behind and discover how to streamline your process to attract and retain top talent.

1. Quit overlooking key recruitment metrics

Without tracking data analytics and key performance indicators (KPIs), it’s challenging to identify bottlenecks and areas for improvement in the recruitment process. This can lead to inefficient hiring and missed opportunities to optimize. Data-driven decision-making is essential for modern recruitment strategies.

Our top tip? Investing in a robust applicant tracking system (ATS) that provides detailed analytics on your recruitment process can help. Track metrics such as time-to-fill, candidate drop-out rates, or interviews per hire. For example, if you notice high drop-out rates after the first interview, this might be a sign of underlying issues within your organisation. Regularly reviewing these KPIs will help you make informed decisions and continuously improve your hiring process.

2. Ditch long recruitment processes

Prolonged recruitment processes are a significant pain point for candidates, leading to increased drop-out rates and frustration, with 38% reporting elevated anxiety levels as a result. Candidates are reporting longer processes and waits for interviews than ever before. With top candidates receiving multiple offers simultaneously, a lengthy process can cause them to lose interest and accept positions somewhere else.

A streamlined recruitment process will have a better chance at keeping candidates engaged. This can be achieved by reducing the number of interview rounds, implementing standardized assessments, but most importantly, by automating technology in processes such as background checks or interview scheduling. A quicker process not only improves candidate experience, but also allows your organization to secure top talent before competitors do.

3. Stop interview scheduling delays

Delays in scheduling interviews are majorly off-putting to candidates. Our annual research indicates that 43% of candidates have dropped out of the recruitment process because of the time it took to schedule a first interview. The back and forth communication to find a mutually convenient time can lead to significant delays, causing candidates to feel undervalued and neglected—or even fall through the cracks. This is even more important when considering candidates find poor communication is the most frustrating part of the hiring process.

Implementing an automated scheduling system that allows candidates to choose their own interview slots can significantly speed up the process. This not only saves time for the recruitment team, but also empowers candidates and reduces their anxiety.

4. No more leaving candidates in the dark

Ghosting candidates, or failing to communicate with them throughout the entire process can severely damage your employer brand. Our research highlights that lack of responsiveness is a significant frustration for many candidates, but especially for 34% of neurodiverse candidates. When candidates are left in the dark about their application status, they are more likely to drop out and share their negative experiences online, deterring other potential candidates.

Establish a communication protocol where candidates receive updates at every stage of the process. Even if a candidate is not moving forward, a rejection email that provides feedback and acknowledges their efforts can maintain a positive relationship. Implementing email templates for each stage can streamline this process and ensure no candidate is left without communication. Personalized communication shows that you value your candidates’ time and effort, enhancing your employer brand, making them more willing to refer others. 

5. Say goodbye to manual scheduling

If you haven’t guessed by now, one of the biggest things that could be setting you back is not adding an automated scheduling tool to your workflow. Manual scheduling is not only time-consuming but also prone to errors such as scheduling conflicts, miscommunication, and an inability to account for last-minute changes. Additionally, a significant number of candidates clearly prefer an automated system for scheduling interviews over lengthy exchanges of communication.

Candidates want their time to be valued – 70% choose roles based on the smoothness of the recruitment process. Scheduling automation reduces the back-and-forth communication, ensuring interviews are booked promptly, as well as minimizing scheduling conflicts. Additionally, recruiters can opt to send reminders and updates to both candidates and interviewers, significantly lowering the chances of no-shows. Integrating the right tool with your current ATS can provide valuable insights into key performance indicators (KPIs). For instance, Cronofy’s integration with Greenhouse and Lever allows recruiters to track metrics like time-to-schedule, time-to-hire, and overall time saved. By leveraging automation for scheduling and communication, recruiters can focus more on meaningful interactions with candidates, making more informed decisions without the need for a lengthy interview process.

Here's what you can do next

By keeping hiring cycles efficient, maintaining consistent communication, leveraging data analytics, and letting go of manual scheduling, you can significantly enhance your company's recruitment performance. One of the most important takeaways of this article is that automating interview part of the hiring process would have a direct impact on many of these bottlenecks.

Book a demo with us to find out how our scheduling tool can make your hiring process more efficient and improve your candidate experience.